Zombiefreak wrote:Fake meaning not really bonsai but something that is marketed at like walmart and loews, where yes they are real trees there just not 7 yrs old in the form of bonsai training. The trees that some stores carry like money trees and such that are marketed to most people who think that all there is to bonsai is a tiny tree in a tiny pot. Essentially thats true but we know there is alot more work involved than what I so simply stated a moment ago. If I'm still not clear in my explanation I will elaborate later as you said I'm off now to go do real world stuff

Oh Malsai! [Broadly] Some folks get specific and say Wal-martsai, Lowsai, H-Deposai, ect....
I agree they are not bonsai, They are cuttings dying in cute little pots.
Wait, I must correct myself. They are
disgustingly overpriced cuttings dying in cute little pots.
Yes, I know exactly what you mean
The
exact same 15$
[Minimum]you spend on that lump of a ginseng ficus, That Juniper cutting that looks like someone stuck a juniper branch in a bunch of rocks [uh- because that's what it is], Or the 'Styled' digital '5' shaped bonsai of indeterminate origin,
[All of which are stuck in some soil containing the
wrong kind of peat and sent out to die among the masses]
Do we all still remember that 15$ we were talking about?...
It could have bought THIS:
[img]https://img170.imageshack.us/img170/5743/contestbwoodbeforeht2.jpg[/img]
This is a Japanese Boxwood bought from Lowes for $13US it is in a 3G pot & about 2' high from the soil to the apex. You may not think that it looks like much But allways remember you need to look at potetial stock from all angles. There are actually TWO twunks in there!
Both with suitable lines to them.
When I got done with my initial styling [Pruning and wiring] {I want to emphasise it was in no way required to repot it and the fact is I took a signifigant risk in doing it. One must gradually work down to a smaller pot- this one is a training pot to be technical about it, This spring it was moved again to a even more shallow pot.}
...At any rate, After the initial styling it looked like this: 16" high [from soil] with a 4" nebari spread....
[img]https://img208.imageshack.us/img208/6305/1780finalsubmissionsbonsaichatorgstylingcontestbox711we5.jpg[/img]
I was lucky enough to win a contest with the styling of this stock which allowed me the nerve to ask Walter Pall for a critique.
[If you don't know his work see his gallery here, It is world class: https://walter-pall.de/galerie.htm]
[The following visual images of this tree should be credited to Walter Pall.]
Mr. Pall was gracious enough to critique my tree and in fact he liked my efforts. As I had allready voiced my opinion that this tree was destined for an oval cream pot, Imagine my surprise when the first virtual of future options by Walter was this :
[url=https://img242.imageshack.us/my.php?image=1945critiqueynotscontestentrybox71132169ut4.jpg][img]https://img242.imageshack.us/img242/308/1945critiqueynotscontestentrybox71132169ut4.th.jpg[/img][/url]
Of course he had more than just one idea:
[url=https://img245.imageshack.us/my.php?image=1946critiqueynotscontestentrybox71133513lr8.jpg][img]https://img245.imageshack.us/img245/2924/1946critiqueynotscontestentrybox71133513lr8.th.jpg[/img][/url]
In fact he had more than two! World Class Indeed

:
[url=https://img165.imageshack.us/my.php?image=1947critiqueynotscontestentrybox71135160pd6.jpg][img]https://img165.imageshack.us/img165/4479/1947critiqueynotscontestentrybox71135160pd6.th.jpg[/img][/url]
Take a nice long look at those last three pictures [or if you flatter me... last four pictures]....$13 it cost me. Now, Ask yourself do you really want to spend your money on that cutting with the rocks glued on top?....
Do you really?
[Mind you I had to dig and search and quest for it, Which was
totally worth it IMO. Bonsai hunting in nurseries is a joy in itself

.
And I have a decent eye for 'seeing the tree within']
This is an example of the phrase 'Little bonsai do not grow up to be big bonsai'.
Instead
Big trees and shrubs are cut back to be bonsai, Cut FAR Far far back and then grown out.
Not put in a tiny pot where they grow large, They won't.
Not in a human lifetime anyway.
Yes Zombiefreak, I know malsai.
You may even see me looking a bit sad standing by the table of them at lowes. [They know I am a bonsai guy, They also know I don't purchase the lowesai,
and why.]
You won't see me bring one home though, I can build a better tree for less money at home..

And it's fun.
And ZF, Thanks for your interest and for posting.
Later,
ynot [img]https://img241.imageshack.us/img241/1939/u4jchinaec9.gif[/img]
EDIT: Here is a progression of pictures of this boxwood in widget form:
https://s7.photobucket.com/albums/y291/novusordo1/Japanese%20Boxwood/?action=view¤t=1161759616.pbw