I got this in a succulent pot many decades ago. I had thought for many years it was gone, until I was digging around looking for something else and I found the pot - this was the only thing in it that survived and it was just barely hanging on so I did the unthinkable and transplanted it, well it survived and has said thank you.
These two I got last year, I found them sickly in a back spot at Walmart and did not think they would live either.
These are some Chocolate Soldier I got a few days ago, they seem to have held on.
This one I got about 2 years ago and it went very bad brown a few months ago, thought it was a gonner, so I took off all the dead and replanted the live ones that fell off in my hand, they took and are doing well, though still small - I am happy about it
This is my first post on a forum and I think I put the images up backwards.