Is it possible? Directions always say direct sow.
El Nino has affected my spring schedule and my plot is not ready for planting. My daughter was dying to plants some carrots, so I decided to give it a go in some seedling trays.
Is there any chance of this working out?
- applestar
- Mod
- Posts: 30551
- Joined: Thu May 01, 2008 7:21 pm
- Location: Zone 6, NJ (3/M)4/E ~ 10/M(11/B)
I've done it before. Considering how long it takes them to sprout, starting them in more controlled environment is attractive. On the other hand, the seeds can be sowed very early outside --- it just takes as much as 3 weeks for them to sprout and you have to make sure to keep the seedbed from drying out. Some people recommend putting a piece of wood/board on top of the soil over the seeds initially.
You can't wait too long to transplant -- no more than two true leaves ...and by then the root can be 2 inches long. The single delicate taproot is what turns into the carrot, and breaking it or even the root finding the bottom of the tray could/will result in kinking or branching.
To transplant, I found it easiest to either remove with cushion of soil cradling it *or* completely bareroot it by floating and rinsing in a bowl of water. Make a deep hole so as not to let the taproot get bent and wide enough to see/maneuver, hold the seedling up against one side of the hole and fill in, making sure not to bury the crown.
...very tedious. Not sure I will try this again unless I can come up with/find a better technique
You can't wait too long to transplant -- no more than two true leaves ...and by then the root can be 2 inches long. The single delicate taproot is what turns into the carrot, and breaking it or even the root finding the bottom of the tray could/will result in kinking or branching.
To transplant, I found it easiest to either remove with cushion of soil cradling it *or* completely bareroot it by floating and rinsing in a bowl of water. Make a deep hole so as not to let the taproot get bent and wide enough to see/maneuver, hold the seedling up against one side of the hole and fill in, making sure not to bury the crown.
...very tedious. Not sure I will try this again unless I can come up with/find a better technique
Theres no need to pregrow carrots, you can sow them weeks before last frost date. If you live somewhere with real cold winters you can even sow them in fall. This wont be for you in CA but just to state how easy they are to grow. I never heard of anyone doing anything but directsowing them.
A plant always grows the roots first. When you see it above soil, it has its first small root/roots already.
You can probably make it, but it feels less than optimal to me.
Applestar has the experience so try with the method mentioned above.
A plant always grows the roots first. When you see it above soil, it has its first small root/roots already.
You can probably make it, but it feels less than optimal to me.
Applestar has the experience so try with the method mentioned above.
-
- Greener Thumb
- Posts: 1356
- Joined: Mon Apr 13, 2015 9:02 pm
- Location: Port Alberni, B.C. Canada, Zone 7 (+?)
I agree with applestar. You can transplant carrots. I'm sure I've done it before but did'nt keep records. I guess all the caveats would apply though, about not damaging the root and transplanting quick, before it gets too long. I think I germinated them in soil blocks, snipping to one seedling per block to avoid having to thin once they're in the ground. That's a chore I hate. On the other hand there's that you-tube of the guy who doesn't thin at all and harvests them by the handful. There's all kinds of ways ......
- Allyn
- Green Thumb
- Posts: 480
- Joined: Tue Mar 03, 2009 5:38 pm
- Location: Mississippi Gulf Coast - zone 8b
I agree with Applestar. That's how I do it. I start them in jiffy pellets and then move them to five-gallon SiPs as soon as I see true leaves starting to form. Starting them in jiffy pellets, I have to make sure to rip open the bottom of the netting when I put them out or the carrots end up with a weird little 'waist' about a half an inch from the top of the carrot. I put nine or ten in a 5-gallon bucket.
- Gary350
- Super Green Thumb
- Posts: 7428
- Joined: Mon Mar 23, 2009 1:59 pm
- Location: TN. 50 years of gardening experience.
It is best to plant carrot seeds in rows. Carrots are interesting plants it takes about 3 weeks for seeds to sprout. Cut 2 liter soft drink bottles length wise place them over your seed row like mini green houses seeds come up sooner. Plant seeds in the snow then cover them with bottles. By the time my seeds come up and my carrots are looking good it is 90 degrees here in TN. I pull to thin the rows and eat all the small carrots before it gets hot. In hot weather carrots get woody and hard as a pine board with less flavor than a pine board and the tops are bitter. I leave my carrots until Oct cool weather makes the carrots soft and have good flavor. A month of cool weather carrots are ready to pull and eat. Tops are excellent in salad or cooked like Spanish. If the soil freezes and the carrots can not been pulled up just wait until spring when the soil is not frozen they pull up easy and taste good.
- jal_ut
- Super Green Thumb
- Posts: 7447
- Joined: Sun Jan 18, 2009 10:20 pm
- Location: Northern Utah Zone 5
Ya, go ahead and transplant those carrots. What have you to lose? As noted we don't usually transplant carrots. Just plant the seed where they will grow. These are cool weather plants and the seed can be planted in your garden plot early as soon as the soil dries out enough to work it in the Spring. Early April at this location.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7bIFghIX5U
Was looking on youtube and this one came up, thought it could fit here. Allthough is not about transplanting but some good tips on how sow them. And why we generally don't transplant them.
Offcourse you should transplant them, I'm just encourage you to in the future focus on the crops that will benefit you most to pregrow, in the end it will make gardening alot easier and fun.
Was looking on youtube and this one came up, thought it could fit here. Allthough is not about transplanting but some good tips on how sow them. And why we generally don't transplant them.
Offcourse you should transplant them, I'm just encourage you to in the future focus on the crops that will benefit you most to pregrow, in the end it will make gardening alot easier and fun.
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 274
- Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2010 6:41 pm
- Location: Far Upper Alabama
The only way I could get mine to grow was to do the transplant method. Yeah, my carrots were crooked and bent at harvest time, I didn't care! That's the only way I could get them to grow. Besides as I always say, "When your bodies done with them after eating, they look like...................................... well, you get the idea and they were plenty good.