You did good, Dave!
I've had jack o'lantern pumpkins that failed to turn orange before frost. (cool nights thru the growing season) Some of those ripened indoors, others rotted before Halloween
. Yours looks like it should be fine.
It was important for me to find an early-maturing variety. I've grown RockStar for about 5 years and they do what they need to do . . . for setting outside the door with a candle in them on the last day of October!!
About the best performing "pumpkin pie" pumpkin for my garden isn't a pumpkin at all. It is Burgess Buttercup squash. They have always given me delicious filling for Thanksgiving & Christmas pies!