Just Joined the Site

[tcjewell]

Hello,

I'd like to get some feedback to some of my compositions . These are Ulmus parvifolia Chinese Elm , Both over 14 yrs. old . What do you think?

[tomc]

Hello,

I'd like to get some feedback to some of my compositions . These are Ulmus parvifolia Chinese Elm , Both over 14 yrs. old . What do you think?

I think you have listed no place of these trees residence. Indoor or outdoor bench space. Or season the photos were taken.

I think the deeper pot will present problems when it comes time to repot. Which leads to: if you didn't grow them for the past fourteen years, I must remain a sceptic.

[Gnome]

tcjewell,

Hello and welcome to the site. I much prefer the first tree to the second. The exaggerated S curve does not appeal to me.

Do you have any issues with black spot fungus? I'm about ready to give up on my Chinese Elms.

Norm

P.S. Please update your profile to include a general location.

[vegetablesteve]

I also prefer the first one. They both look nice though. I'd say:"keep up the good work"

greets,